Exeter and Andover are both coeducational boarding schools with day students, both use Gateway to Prep Schools, both are need-blind, and both release decisions on March 10. The differences that matter for a family applying to both are the deadline (January 15 at Exeter, February 1 at Andover), the testing options, the interview, and how classes are taught. This guide compares them using only what each school states on its own site.
Who this is for
This is for families building a list that includes both schools. It does not rank them. Both schools describe their own programs, and fit depends on your child. Details below reflect each school's admissions pages in November 2026, and you should confirm them on the schools' sites before you plan.
The schools at a glance
- Exeter: Exeter, New Hampshire. Founded in 1781. The school reports 1,096 students in 2026-27, including 890 boarders and 206 day students, and a 6:1 student to teacher ratio.
- Andover: Andover, Massachusetts. Founded in 1778. Andover's admission page shows 1167 students from 56 countries and 43 U.S. states and territories, and 850 boarding and 310 day students (marked as numbers reflecting a typical year). Andover's admission page does not state a student to teacher ratio.
Exeter reports about 10 to 15 percent of its senior class is new each fall, and says most one-year students are postgraduates. Both schools accept applicants to the 12th grade and a postgraduate year.
Application deadlines and decisions
- Exeter: the application deadline for the 2027-28 school year cycle is January 15, and decisions are released March 10. The financial aid deadline is also January 15. The interview must be completed by January 15.
- Andover: the admission application deadline is February 1, 2027, and the financial aid application is due the same day.Andover: the admission application deadline was February 1, 2027, and the financial aid application was due the same day. Andover's FAQ gives March 10 as its decision release date. Andover says interviews are conducted through the month of January.
That makes Exeter's deadline roughly two weeks earlier, with the same decision date. Neither school's admissions site states a reply date that we could find. Check your decision letters.
Application parts
Both schools start with the Candidate Profile in Gateway to Prep Schools, and both email portal login credentials within 24 hours.
- Student writing, Exeter: two essays of 200 to 500 words each, with prompts available in the applicant portal.
- Student writing, Andover: an Essay Response and a Graded Writing Sample in Gateway, and a Short Video Response in Andover's portal. A multimedia link, such as a portfolio or performance video, is optional.
- Parent statement: Exeter has a parent statement in its portal. Andover has a Parent/Guardian Statement in Gateway.
- Recommendations, Exeter: a current principal or guidance counselor, current English and math teachers, and an adult who knows the applicant well. A special interest recommendation is optional.
- Recommendations, Andover: a principal or counselor, a current English teacher, a current math teacher, and a personal recommendation (a former teacher in any subject is acceptable). A special interest recommendation and an Arts or Athletics Supplement are optional.
- Transcripts: Exeter requires current and previous year transcripts. Andover asks for first-term grades from the current year and the prior two academic years, and a complete high school transcript for 12th grade and postgraduate applicants.
Testing policy
Neither school is test-optional.
- Exeter: grade 9 applicants submit the Upper Level SSAT or ISEE. Grades 10 and 11 submit one of the SSAT, ISEE, PSAT (NMSQT), SAT, PreACT, or ACT. Grade 12 and postgraduate applicants submit one of the PSAT (NMSQT), SAT, PreACT, or ACT.
- Andover: students must submit one of the SSAT (Upper Level), ISEE (Upper Level), PSAT, SAT, or ACT. Andover's apply page does not break the list down by grade.
- English proficiency: Exeter strongly recommends but does not require the TOEFL, IELTS, or Duolingo English Test for some applicants. Andover asks applicants from non-English-medium schools to take one of those tests.
Both schools use their own score-sending codes, which differ, so register each test with the right codes for each school.
Interview
Exeter requires an interview for all applicants, in person, online, or by video submission. Andover lets applicants supplement the application with one of an on-campus interview, a virtual interview, or a recording. Andover's pages do not say the interview is mandatory, so confirm with the admission office rather than assume.
Application fee
Exeter's fee is $60 for all applicants, with fee waivers for students intending to apply for financial aid. Andover's tuition and financial aid page lists $60, or $125 for international students, due with the Preliminary Application. Andover's apply page mentions a testing fee waiver for financial aid applicants, requested through its portal.
Financial aid
- Need-blind: both schools say admission does not depend on financial need.
- Full need: Exeter says it meets 100 percent of demonstrated need with grants. Andover says it meets 100 percent of demonstrated need, with grants rather than loans.
- Merit: Exeter says it does not provide scholarships based on merit. Andover's aid page does not mention merit scholarships.
- Exeter extras: tuition-free attendance for accepted students with family income below $150,000, if the family meets additional criteria that Exeter lists. Exeter reports that 49 percent of students receive aid.
- Andover: reports that 47 percent of students receive aid.
- How to apply: Exeter uses the Clarity Application ($65 submission fee). Andover says families submit aid applications at the same time as the admission application.
Program structure
Exeter is known for Harkness: twelve students and one teacher around an oval table discussing the subject at hand. Andover's academics page reports an average class size of 13, says classes vary by department and discipline "from discussion and inquiry-based to immersive and experiential," and lists more than 300 courses. Andover's page does not describe a Harkness format.
Common mistakes
- Using one calendar for both. The deadlines differ by about two weeks.
- Assuming matching requirements. The essay structure, recommendation lists, and test lists are not the same.
- Reusing portal essays. Write for each school's prompts.
- Skipping the interview at Andover. The page says one option is part of the application, so plan one.
FAQ
Do both schools require testing?
Yes. Each school asks every applicant to submit a test from its list.
Which has the earlier deadline?
Exeter, on January 15. Andover's is February 1, 2027.Exeter's was January 15. Andover's is February 1, 2027.Exeter's was January 15. Andover's was February 1, 2027.
Do both release decisions on the same day?
Both state March 10.
Can I use the same recommendations?
The roles overlap, but you request them separately for each school, and Andover requires a current English and a current math teacher too.
If you are juggling two applications, the programs page explains how we organize the work. See also the admissions overview and timeline.
Sources
- Exeter: How to Apply
- Exeter: Admissions
- Exeter: About
- Exeter: Harkness
- Andover: How to Apply
- Andover: Admission
- Andover: Admission FAQs
- Andover: Tuition and Financial Aid
- Andover: Academics
ExeterPrep by EduAvenues is an independent service, not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Phillips Exeter Academy.